
You Can See Everything review: Mind-boggling conversation starter
What do you do when your subject disappears (or goes to prison) halfway through your documentary? Do you give up on the project or find a creative way to keep telling the story? With You Can See Everything, directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim go for the latter and turn this into an unusual documentary-docudrama hybrid.
Thirty-four days before Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes reports to prison to start her 11-year sentence in 2023, a documentary crew goes to her and her partner Billy Evans‘ beachside home in San Diego. Fielder, initially meant to be an off-camera observer, eventually becomes a subject and even lives with them for two weeks.
There is a reason You Can See Everything has captured the zeitgeist and everybody’s talking about it – it’s really hard to wrap your head around and you’ll come away wondering what you’ve just seen. Holmes and Evans instigated the documentary and promised “radical transparency”, insisting she’s innocent and has nothing to hide, but then seem incapable of giving straightforward answers (particularly in relation to Theranos). They can’t provide a solid shred of evidence proving her blood-testing device worked and seem to think their version of the truth is different to other people’s. You will come away needing a massive debrief afterwards to dissect Holmes, her power dynamic with Evans and the intriguing relationship between documentarian (Fielder) and subject.
Usually with a documentary, you come away knowing the subject better, but I still don’t really know Holmes. There are little insights here and there, sure, but she remains at a distance, unknowable and unfathomable. Is she lying or being deceptive? Or does she truly believe that she didn’t do anything wrong? And why would they want a documentary crew there in the first place? Rather than make the most of their time together before she goes to prison? If she was guilty, why would she do it? And if she was truly innocent, why didn’t she offer up proof? She is impossible to work out and I don’t know if we ever saw her authentic self.
The film is gripping, fascinating and often funny, due to their baffling conversations (shot in extreme close-ups) and Fielder’s reactions and awkwardness lurking around their house (it’s rather meta as the camera is watching him observing them). It really comes into its own and takes on a whole new identity once Holmes goes to prison and they have to get creative to continue a documentary without its subject. Without access to her, Fielder turns to reenactments to bring off-camera private conversations to life and dissects their meaning and his interpretation. Evans also becomes a bigger character (he does not come across well) and it becomes clear that Fielder feels protective of Holmes and has friction with Evans.
The film is two hours and 54 minutes, which is crazy for a documentary. It is mostly justified because a lot happens over the three and a half year process, but I do think they spend too much time pulling apart what a line or an action meant and analysing it in granular detail. I only began to feel the hefty runtime in the last half hour though and by its very nature, it can’t tie things up in a neat bow and offer us a resolution.
You Can See Everything is a risky, inventive and experimental film that plays with the form and refuses to be defined. It’s so unique, perplexing and unusual that you’ll come away not really knowing what to make of it. I recommend watching with others – there is a lot to unpack and you’ll want to talk to somebody about it.
In cinemas from Friday 20th November
